Legislation would protect health care privacy


STATE HOUSE – Sen. Gayle Goldin and Rep. Susan R. Donovan will speak about their legislation to protect the health care privacy of Rhode Islanders tomorrow at an online event hosted by the Rhode Island Health and Privacy Alliance (RIHPA) and the Rhode Island Coalition Against Domestic Violence (RICADV).

The sponsors and advocates for the bill will be urging support for this critical legislation during the event, which will be held on Facebook Live Thursday, April 1, from 3 p.m. to 3:30 p.m. via this link: ­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­ https://fb.me/e/2z8RQu7vI.

The legislation (2021-S 0062, 2021-H 5370) would allow people to request their insurance company send health communications directly to them instead of a parent or spouse. Privacy between health care providers and patients is essential to the health care relationship. The bill would protect survivors of domestic and sexual violence, young adults and others who may have their privacy violated by insurance communications.

“While federal laws have long guaranteed health care privacy rights between a patient and clinician, those protections fall apart when the health insurance industry sends information about the visit to the patient’s home. The details included in the statements that are mailed to insurance policyholders can discourage patients from seeking a medical intervention that they need. We want to make sure everyone feels safe to seek the full range of care: from mental health, to reproductive care, to getting a broken bone set. Our bill will provide an option to protect patients who need health care without their family knowing all of the details,” said Senator Goldin (D-Dist. 3, Providence).

Many insurance companies routinely send disclosure statements – known as Explanations of Benefits (EOBs) — to the policyholder’s home address whenever anyone on the plan receives a health care service. The EOB describes the service, such as “psychotherapy,” and lists the service provider. Some EOBs are addressed to the patient receiving the service if the patient is a teen or adult, but by default the EOB is sent to the policyholder’s mailing address. For instance, a spouse living in a domestic violence shelter might access mental health counseling, and their abusive partner who is the insurance policyholder could then receive an EOB in the mail, which would reveal the survivor’s private health information with potentially violent consequences.

Under the bill, health insurers would be required to offer a confidential communications request form, which allows any insured person to request any medical information sent by an insurer be communicated to an alternate address, secure email address, or alternate phone number designated by that person. In other words, a patient who is not the policyholder can redirect their health information communications to them and keep it private.

“Ultimately, this bill is about keeping Rhode Islanders safe and eliminating roadblocks that keep people from seeking the treatment they need. Adult children on a parent’s health insurance policy should not have to worry about that information being shared. And no one should be put in danger by having their personal health care information sent to someone with whom they would rather not share it,” said Representative Donovan (D-Dist. 69, Bristol, Portsmouth).

The COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated already existing public health problems that cause suffering for many Rhode Islanders. Overdose fatalities continue to increase in the state. More young adults are attempting suicide. Domestic violence calls to the statewide helpline have spiked. Sexually transmitted infection rates were increasing pre-pandemic and remain high. Against this backdrop, Rhode Island insurance companies engage in practices that unintentionally violate patient privacy, making it harder for people to receive needed health care and access that care safely.

RICADV Director of Policy and Advocacy John Wesley said, “Access to health services is vital for victims of domestic violence. Unfortunately, many survivors may forego needed medical or mental health attention if their abuser is the policy holder, because they fear their abuser will be alerted to their use of medical services. Abusers are known to interfere with victim’s access to health care and this disclosure from insurance letters could escalate the violence the victim is experiencing. We have seen this consequence firsthand by working with survivors.”

Dr. Jack Rusley, Rhode Island physician and co-chairperson of RIHPA, said, “In my experience working with young people in my clinic, many want to take steps toward being healthy — whether it may be engaging with mental health care or taking a medication to prevent HIV — but they decide to forgo these treatments, out of fear their parents would get an EOB. While the stated aim of EOBs is to promote transparency, these letters have unintended consequences that put the patients I work with and many others in a position where they must make an impossible choice. The result is often a delay in care, or avoidance all together. These letters have a chilling effect.”

Dr. Joanna Brown, Rhode Island physician and co-chairperson of RIHPA, said, “I’ve seen young adults afraid to get mental health counseling or STD testing because they weren’t comfortable having their parents find out. The last thing we need right now are barriers to health care, particularly for vulnerable youth. Insurance protocol shouldn’t get in the way of the doctor-patient relationship.”

 “We applaud Sen. Goldin and Rep. Donovan for introducing this crucial legislation and encourage lawmakers in both chambers to pass this critical bill during the 2021 session,” said Dr. Brown.

In 2018, a cross-sector, multi-disciplinary coalition of groups came together to form the Rhode Island Health and Privacy Alliance (RIHPA) with the aim to prevent EOB-related privacy breaches. The co-chairpersons of RIHPA are Joanna Brown, MD, MPH; Jack Rusley, MD, MHS; and John Wesley, JD. RIHPA members are: Rhode Island Medical Society; Rhode Island Coalition Against Domestic Violence; Planned Parenthood of Southern New England; ACLU of RI; American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (RI Chapter), American Academy of Pediatrics (RI Chapter); Substance Use, Policy, Education and Recovery PAC; RI Public Health Institute; Women’s Fund of Rhode Island; VICTA; Open Door Health; Rhode Island Public Health Institute; Amy Nunn, MS, ScD; Philip Chan,  MD, MS; Don Operario, PhD; Dupe Akinrimisi; Abigail Donaldson, MD;  and Emily Allen, MD.




For an electronic version of this and all press releases published by the Legislative Press and Public Information Bureau, please visit our website at www.rilegislature.gov/pressrelease


Follow us on social media!

President Biden says Congress has to step up and act on gun control. While speaking at the White House today, Biden said the gun epidemic "has to end now." He lamented that it seems like there is a mass shooting every day.        Attorney General Merrick Garland is rescinding limits on consent decrees the Trump administration put in place to keep the Department of Justice from seeking reforms on police departments. Garland's order returns the D-O-J to the policies in place before then-Attorney General Jeff Sessions imposed restrictions. The consent decrees are court-ordered agreements used to resolve violations of law, or systemic misconduct by state or local law enforcement.        The Ann Arbor Police Chief is giving an update on the Briarwood Mall shooting in Michigan. Chief Michael Cox says the victim suffered gunshot wounds in his "arm area" and the injuries are non-life-threatening. Police don't know how many suspects there are as they continue to secure the mall.        Vaccine hesitancy by staff is a major concern at Pennsylvania's nursing homes. The State Department of Health says only 52-percent of staff has opted to get immunized for COVID-19. On the other hand, 80-percent of Pennsylvania's nursing home patients have been vaccinated.       Liberty University is suing its former president Jerry Falwell Junior for ten-million dollars. The suit alleges that Falwell withheld scandalous and potentially damaging information from Liberty's board of trustees. Falwell apparently "led a scheme to cover up the illicit conduct" that damaged the Christian university and its reputation.        Actress Helen McCrory is dead at 52. McCrory is best known for her roles as Narcissa Malfoy in the Harry Potter film series and as Aunt Polly in the television series Peaky Blinders. Her husband, actor Damian Lewis, broke the news on his Twitter page.